In an October 16, 2026, episode of NPR’s Code Switch podcast, host Gene Demby examines claims that right-wing ideology has entered gym culture and asks whether the idea of fitness itself is ripe for politicization or inherently fascist. Guests include left-leaning political commentator and fitness enthusiast Hasan Piker, historian Natalia Mehlman Petrzela (author of Fit Nation), and University of Michigan women’s and gender studies professor Ava Purkiss (author of Fit Citizens).
The episode notes phenomena such as thin-blue-line flags in gyms, fitness influencers sliding into vaccine skepticism or other right-leaning views, and “active clubs”—decentralized groups of young men who work out together while organizers reportedly seek to draw them toward white nationalism. Demby frames Piker as a figure in the “swoletariat,” leftists who aim to reclaim gym spaces from what they see as fascist-leaning culture, sometimes with slogans like “a fascist worked out today. Did you?” Piker, who has drawn young male audiences with a mix of socialist commentary and weightlifting, says he does not view fitness as inherently fascist. He acknowledges that uncritical thinking can lead people toward right-wing ideas involving “body fascism and eugenics,” but rejects the broader framing.
Purkiss offers the strongest linkage. She describes fascism (in both “big F” and “small f” forms) as the consolidation of state power, authority, and coercion that minimizes democracy. When the state, institutions, or influential people promote fitness, she argues, it can appear harmless or even beneficial while serving as a proxy to sort people: hardworking versus lazy, self-restrained versus “greedy and insatiable,” those who contribute through bodily sacrifice versus those who “take from the nation by getting fat off of the government.” She calls this a potential “tool of soft fascism, maybe even actual fascism.” Purkiss ties the concept historically to moral judgments, eugenics (distinguishing the “fit” from the “unfit”), class distinctions between purposeful leisure exercise and labor, military readiness, and racial hierarchies. She and other guests discuss early-20th-century shifts after World War I, presidential fitness campaigns (including John F. Kennedy’s “The Soft American”), and resistance to state-directed exercise programs on the grounds that such practices resembled those of fascist or totalitarian regimes, including the Hitler Youth.
Petrzela contextualizes American fitness culture as an expression of individualism and self-improvement through visible bodily effort, while noting its historical intersections with citizenship and national identity.
The episode has drawn sharp criticism. Outlets including the New York Post and NewsBusters highlighted Purkiss’s comments (including reported references to racialized judgments around discipline, BMI, and disability) and framed the segment as equating ordinary exercise or healthy living with fascism. Clips circulated widely online, prompting mockery and debate about the boundaries of academic and media analysis of fitness.
In short, Code Switch uses historical research and contemporary observations to argue that fitness ideals have long been entangled with power, hierarchy, and exclusion, while guests differ on whether the practice itself is inherently political or fascist. The resulting discussion has highlighted ongoing tensions over the politicization of health, bodies, and culture.
SOURCES:
Why fascists love “fitness” : Code Switch : NPR
Woke Michigan professor stunningly argues physical fitness leads to fascism: ‘That’s racialized’
NPR Podcast Explores Connections Between Fitness Culture and Fascism
Why fascists love “fitness” Transcript – Code Switch
Why fascists love “fitness” · Code Switch – Podwise
Why fascists love “fitness” – Code Switch
